This commit is contained in:
pablo 2022-07-18 23:24:29 +02:00
parent f8929081b6
commit 5e5ae0078e
7 changed files with 229 additions and 12 deletions

View file

@ -11,9 +11,11 @@ of the contents:
- `plan.md`: an overview of the general approach.
- `register.xlsx`: a small spreadsheet to keep track of all transactions.
- `simulation`: stuff to simulation the operation saylor itself according to
- `simulation`: stuff to simulate the operation saylor itself according to
historical data. Was mainly used to make the decision of pulling the trigger,
but it would be interesting to compare in the future how things went against
these simulations.
- `xpub`: the xpub of the cold wallet.
- `evangelism`: materials for my post series trackign the evolution of the
operation.

View file

@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
# Operation Saylor Episode - X/120
Hi again and welcome to another episode of the Operation Saylor. This is update
number X, corresponding to MONTH, YEAR.
If you are reading this for first time, you might want to
check [Episode 1](ADD LINK) to get in context.
---
## Stats
- BTC Stack:
- Current value in €
- € in:
- Paid back to bank:
- Outstanding debt:
- Installments to go:
Charts
- BTC churn chart
- Value of stack vs Outstanding debt with the bank
---
## Log
<Explain something interesting here>
## FAQ

View file

@ -0,0 +1,152 @@
# Operation Saylor Episode - 1/120
Hi there, welcome to Operation Saylor series.
I have decided to take a loan to invest in Bitcoin. I will make a series of
monthly updates here to track the evolution of this operation I have dubbed
Saylor (in honor of [Michael Saylor](https://twitter.com/saylor), whose bold
bet on Bitcoin and willigness to promote it where strong inspirations for this
adventure).
My goal with sharing this experience is to allow everyone to learn whatever can
be learnt from my plan and
execution. [Jamespunk great blog on his DCA path](https://er-bybitcoin.com/)
was and is a great example of how a real life, first person narration can be
very instructive. I hope this series can fulfill a similar role for this
different investment approach.
As this is the first episode, I'll provide some context so that you understand
better this and future updates.
## The Operation
On July 2022, I took a loan with my usual bank. This is an uncollateralized
loan with a fixed amortization schedule. The numbers:
- Principal: 33.000€
- 120 installments in 120 months (10 years)
- APR: 5.99%, APY: 6.16%
- Each installment will be of 366.20€
- Total interesed paid will be 10,944.33€
- Early amortization penalty of 1%
- No opening costs
As this loan has no collateral, there is no margin call or liquidation of any
sort. The loan is completely orthogonal to whatever the evolution of bitcoin's
price is.
During the following six months, my plan is to swap 5.000€/month into bitcoin.
I do this instead of simply lump-suming everyting to softly minimize the risk
of picking a terrible entrypoint.
After these six months, I will have a bitcoin stack of a certain amount and
around 1.000€. From that point on, the plan is to:
- Pay the installments each month.
- Whenever the € stash goes very low, sell a bit of bitcoin back for € to pay
for the next installment. Goal here is to keep as much value in bitcoin as
possible and only go back to € tactically to cover the installments.
- Repeat until 10 years have passed.
As time passes, two scenarios can take place:
- In the SHTF (shit hits the fan) scenario, I run out of bitcoin before the 10
years have passed and I am left with 0 stash and some amount outstanding with
the bank. I will be forced to keep paying the installments from my personal
pocket and Operation Saylor will have turned into a net negative for me. This
could happen both in case a black swan completely destroy bitcoin and its
value, or simply because bitcoin's € price doesn't go up fast enough to make
a net return.
- In the Moon scenario, I manage to pay all the installments by taking small
bites of my bitcoin stack and I still have some amount of btc left in the
end. I will have succesfully earned value with my bet, and I am left with a
nice stack of some unknown value. This would happen in a scenario where
bitcoin behaves the way it tipically has for the past 10 years (or with a
slightly watered-down behaviour in terms of return and volatility) and I get
lucky with the early volatility.
My hope is that Moon scenario will happen, but I am very well aware that SHTF
scenario is a serious possibility.
## Are you crazy stupid? Never borrow money for investing
I am aware that there is a not negligible probability of losing several
thousands of euros with this operation.
But, after carefully judging, I think there is also a significant chance of
getting a great upside. After playing with different simulations and
hypothesis, I decided that the expected outcome looked net positive and decided
to pull the trigger.
I am also taking a calculated risk. Given my personal finances and life
circunstances, the SHTF scenario would be a nasty blow but not a death
sentence. Even if I get hacked on day 1 and lose all the money, I still expect
to have a plate on the table every day and a roof over my head.
## Why make it a series
There are several motivations to doing this.
- Explaning and documenting my plans helps me reflect on them deeply. It's a
bit like a peer review, with the only difference I am reviewing my own plans.
- As discussed before, I find personal, real life stories of bitcoiners and
their actions fascinating. Macro environment analysis, papers, technical and
economical books, ... They are all great reads. But I think sometimes we also
need simple stories from regular people like us, with all the crisp of the
real life and down to earth practical issues. Bitcoin is, after all, a
grassroots, bottom-up phenomenon. It is the small actions of you, me and
everyone else which compose the emergent behaviour of the network.
- I think that, on most forums and communities, there is a dogmatic rejection
to any kinf of idea related to borrowing money for investing. I am the first
to agree that, for most people, most of the time, it is a terrible idea that
should be avoided. But it is also my belief that under the right
circumstances, it is a valid strategy. And so I am slightly pissed off
because this automatic, parrot-like "NeVEr BorRoW tO INvEsT" comments hijack
any kind of honest debate around this. I hope that these series can be
counterbalance this and get people discussing in a calm and thoughtful manner
the possibility of doing something similar to what I am doing. If the angry
mobs hijack my posts anyway, at least I hope that whoever is curious about
the outcomes of taking this seemingly crazy and bonkers course of action can
ignore the deniers and simply read my story.
## Why not simply DCA with a part of your salary isntead
I am. This operation happens on top of my already regular DCA schedule. So you
could say I am doubling down.
As time passes, comparing Operation Saylor to having DCAd the amount equal to
the paid installments will be an interesting analysis.
## So should I do this as well
The answer that most probably fits your circumstances is no.
But, depending on your personal finances, risk aversion, other investments and
what kind of loans and conditions you have access to, there is a chance that
borrowing to invest might be a suitable option for you.
I invite you to run your own analysis and put a lot of thinking into this
decision. During the series, I will share my own train of thought and the
numbers I ran before pulling the trigger.
If you reached this far, thanks for reading. I'll be happy to discuss further
in the comment section.
---
## Stats
- BTC Stack:
- Current value in €:
- € in:
- Paid back to bank:
- Outstanding debt:
- Installments to go:
Charts
- BTC churn chart
- Value of stack vs Outstanding debt with the bank
## Log
<Explain something interesting here>

BIN
paperwork/contrato.pdf Normal file

Binary file not shown.

Binary file not shown.

52
plan.md
View file

@ -14,10 +14,10 @@ The idea of Operation Saylor is to:
The loan I can get through my usual bank (Bankinter) comes with the following
conditions:
- Principal: 33.200€
- Principal: 33.000€
- 120 installments in 120 months
- APR 5,99%, APY6,16%
- Each installment would be of 368,42
- APR 5,99%, APY 6,16%
- Each installment would be of 366,20
- Early amortization penalty of 1%
- No opening costs
@ -38,6 +38,10 @@ happen through four different bank accounts. That will spread the volume enough
across different entities so that no single observe can realize the actual
extent of the operation purchases.
Since the loan amount is 33.000€ and the entry DCA period 6 months, the monthly
buy should be around 5.000€ per month.
## BTC funds storage
The BTC funds from the operation will be stored in two locations:
@ -65,17 +69,45 @@ following way: I will open sub-accounts for Operation Saylor in the four fiat
accounts I am planning on using. All the money related to the Operation will be
recorded in these "virtual" accounts. This way, I will keep it separate from my
personal balance and still be able to reconcile the total account balance with
what will appear in my online banking systems. The origin of these funds will be
a liability account, reflecting that this money doesn't really belong to "me",
but rather to Operation Saylor.
what will appear in my online banking systems. The origin of these funds will
be a liability account, reflecting that this money doesn't really belong to "
me", but rather to Operation Saylor.
Regarding the BTC balance and all purchases and sales, I will run a separate
spreadsheet to record those. That will enable a more flexible tracking and playing
around with data than what gnucash would allow me to, and the operations are
going to be simple enough so that the serious ledger is not missed.
spreadsheet to record those. That will enable a more flexible tracking and
playing around with data than what gnucash would allow me to, and the
operations are going to be simple enough so that the serious ledger is not
missed.
## Expected results
TODO: Summarize the outcomes of my little simulation engine.
## Evangelizing
Operation Saylor is a financial movement that is typically touted as suicidal
and irresponsible. Although it is indeed a very risky movement, I think that
the online community has developed a certain degree of dogmatic rejection about
leveraging to invest in BTC long term. People just mindlessly repeat "don't get
a loan to invest" without providing any thoughts to the nuances around it or
being open to discussing why is it a bad idea.
I think that, with a loan like the one I am getting (uncollateralized, no
margin call) Operation Saylor is not a stupid idea. It is indeed risky, and
there is a chance that I will lose an important chunk of money. So I would like
to spark up debates across the community to fight the rejection dogma, in the
hope that some people might actually discover that this movement suits their
own investment preferences.
To do this, I will post a monthly update on stacker.news. On every update, I
will provide a standard report on how things are going (BTC balance,
outstanding debt, money invested vs current net worth) + an additional, brief
reflection from my side. This could be about the reasoning that led me to run
Operation Saylor, comparing this strategy to a DCA, discussing the fundamentals
that make the operation sensible from a theoretical point of view, etc.
I hope it would get the same kind of traction that the Early Retirement by
Bitcoin blog would get. I feel there is something addictive about these monthly
updates with real people and real numbers and seeing how well or how bad they
are doing. It's as if you were sharing the greed and excitement with them.

Binary file not shown.